Exploring If God Created Evil: A Christian Perspective

Leave a comment / / Updated on: 27th December 2023

did god create evil
Did God create evil? / mrjo2405 via iStock

Evil, in all its forms, has puzzled and troubled humanity since time immemorial.

Regardless of one’s religious or ideological beliefs, the coexistence of a benevolent God with the harsh realities of evil is a concept that begs exploration.

From a Christian perspective, the complexity of this issue takes on a different hue, demanding a deeper dive into the nature of God, the origin of evil, the role of free will and the purpose of suffering.

In the Christian faith, God is perceived as omniscient, omnipotent and perfectly loving.

How then, one may ask, does evil feature in His creation if He is, indeed, all-knowing, all-powerful and all-loving?

It is within this context that we begin our exploration, endeavoring to discern the interplay between God’s character, human autonomy and the enigma of evil.

Pure Presence Shop's Premium Throw Pillow Collection
Pure Presence Shop’s Premium Throw Pillow Collection

The Nature of God

did god create evil
Hands of God / joshblake via iStock

In understanding the Christian faith, one imperative aspect is the comprehension of the undeniable link between the nature of God and the concept of evil.

Deeply convoluted, yet utterly vital to grasp, this theological paradigm has been at the heart of Christian doctrine for centuries.

The question ingeniously weaves through the innocence of Eden, the tumult of Job, and the crucifixion in Golgotha.

It resides in the hearts of every believer wrestling with life’s intricate mystery: How does a loving and all-powerful God align with the existence of evil?

God’s Benevolence and the Enigma of Evil

God, in His benevolent nature, is depicted throughout the sacred scriptures as embodying limpid purity, infinite wisdom, and matchless power.

These attributes are anchored in the divine personhood of God encompassing omniscience, omnipresence, and omnipotence.

Freedom of Choice: Unraveling the Paradox

did god create evil
Battle between darkness and divine light / Ig0rZh via iStock

According to this transcendent nature, God, being wholly good, neither instigates nor rejoices in evil.

Christian theology staunchly reaffirms the truth that God is love, a divine, encompassing affection that overspills into creation.

This love, far from being a mere feeling, seethes with a relentless desire to gift every created being with freedom – the freedom of choice.

But this freedom exposes a paradox – the potential to rebel, to choose contrary to God’s will.

This point is astutely portrayed in the Genesis narrative where Adam and Eve’s disobedience brought the malignance of evil into God’s pristine creation.

Insights from the Book of Job: God’s Sovereignty and the Presence of Evil

Moreover, the book of Job provides a thought-provoking insight into the connection between God’s sovereignty and the presence of evil.

The divine discourse upfrontly acknowledges that though Satan was the perpetrator of Job’s suffering, God’s omniscient authority sanctioned it.

Herein, one finds a deeper realization – the mysterious relationship between God’s eternal wisdom and the reality of evil.

The Cross as the Profoundest Symbol: Divine Love Meeting Human Evil

did god create evil
The crucifix symbolizes hope / Paul Campbell via iStock

However, the cross emerges as the profoundest symbol in this musing.

In the crucible of the cross, divine love met with human evil in an unprecedented drama.

Evil, in its most grotesque form, sentenced the incarnate God to an ignominious death.

God, in His endless mercy, transformed this utter horror into the pinnacle of hope and redemption.

Evil’s Existence and God’s Unchanging Love

The existence of evil does not negate God’s love or question His power.

On the contrary, it illuminates God’s respect for human freedom, His determination not to coerce us into obedience.

Yes, evil exists, but so does a God who redeems, a God who brings light out of profound darkness.

God’s Proximity to Evil: A Transformative Conquest

did god create evil
Jesus Christ carrying the cross up Calvary / wwing via iStock

In an open display to humanity, the crux of Calvary revealed that God does not merely observe from a distance.

He stepped into the odious pit of evil, taking its full brunt upon Himself.

Why?

To quash it, not through annihilation, but through transformation.

God’s nature hence does not conflict with the concept of evil instead, it transcends it by providing redemption.

Divine Protagonist in the Cosmic Struggle: God’s Ultimate Solution

did god create evil
A crucifix within the church

In the great cosmic struggle between good and evil, God is neither the author of evil nor a distant spectator.

He is the divine protagonist who dived headlong into the bitter pool of human suffering and sin.

God’s profound association with evil, therefore, lies not in its creation, but in its ultimate conquest.

His nature aligns with it, not as its source, but as its ultimate solution.

So, let us, as followers of Christ, hold fast to our faith – a faith rooted in a God who overpowers evil through self-sacrificial love.

The Origin of Evil

A question often lingers in the hearts and minds of those exploring faith: Where did evil originate if not from God, according to Biblical teachings?

Delving into Scripture, we trace the birth of evil not to the Creator but rather to the independent actions of creation.

Biblical texts often reveal what can seem paradoxical: God, who is the source of all life and the embodiment of ultimate goodness, allowed the existence of evil.

However, a closer examination of these sacred texts elucidates that evil was never a creation of God – it manifested due to the misuse of free will bestowed upon angels and humans alike.

The Tragic Fall of Lucifer

Revisit the tragic fall of Lucifer, a demonstration of free will gone astray.

Once a beautiful and powerful angel, Lucifer’s pride led him to challenge God’s authority, resulting in his downfall and transformation into Satan (Isaiah 14:12-15; Ezekiel 28:13-19).

This story does not elucidate God’s creation of evil but the birth of evil from an angel’s rebellion against divine authority.

The Fall of Adam and Eve

did god create evil
Adam and Eve being cast out of Paradise / duncan1890 via iStock

Similarly, the ripple of evil spread throughout humanity with the fall of the first humans, Adam and Eve, in the Garden of Eden.

Genesis 3 records their misuse of free will: deceived by the serpent, they disobeyed God’s command, introducing sin and its subsequent consequence – evil – into the human experience.

Here again, evil did not originate from God, but from a transgression against His divine command.

Affirmation of God’s Righteousness

Furthermore, the Scriptures clearly affirm that God is righteous and just (Psalm 11:7), holy and pure (Leviticus 11:44).

James 1:13-14 emphatically states that God cannot be tempted by evil nor does He Himself tempt anyone.

Therefore, attributing the source of evil to God is contrary to the fundamental truths of His nature.

Divine Use of Evil for Ultimate Purposes

did god create evil
God tests Jesus’ faith as He faces temptation / wynnter via iStock

Unquestionably, evil exists.

However, the existence of evil does not diminish God’s sovereignty.

In His divine wisdom, God uses even evil for His ultimate divine purposes.

Consider Joseph’s story in Genesis 50:20 where he declares, “You intended to harm me, but God intended it all for good.

He brought me to this position so I could save the lives of many people.”

A Narrative of Divine Permission

did god create evil
Divine sovereignty and human choice / fcscafeine via iStock

A discerning analysis of Scripture shows that the story of evil is not one of divine origination, but a narrative of divine permission.

It exposes the consequences of free will misused and the triumph of divine purposes over human and satanic applications of free will.

Our Role in the Spiritual Clash

In this spiritual clash between good and evil, believers are called to act.

With faith in God’s sovereignty and love that has already overcome evil through the crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus Christ, believers are to live out their faith, mirror Christ’s love, and push back the darkness of evil.

As Christians, we wrestle not with the question of God’s responsibility for evil, but with our role in owning our choices, resisting the allure of sin, and embodying the victory of Christ.

All this in the confidence that in the final reckoning, God’s justice will prevail, and evil will be eternally vanquished.

Free Will and Evil

While the aforementioned insights delve deep into the root of evil and shape our perspectives – whether it be the biblical understanding of the fall of Lucifer and Adam and Eve, or God’s attributes and stance towards evil – we must further explore the conversation around free will.

The Significance of Free Will in Christian Theology

Humanity’s gift of free will from God is a hallmark of Christian theology.

It places a considerable amount of capacity to initiate or refrain from action into one’s hands.

Human free will, an unconstrained choice to perform deeds – be it good or evil – underscores the extent of trust the Lord has in us.

The Intersection of Free Will and Evil

Free will is the delicate balance on life's scale of choices
Free will is the delicate balance on life’s scale of choices / sommart via iStock

However, as we investigate the implications of free will on the presence of evil, we encounter essential aspects of our faith.

The ability to freely commit to actions, whether they align with God’s will or deviate from it, incites the potential for evil.

Evil is not a direct spawn of free will, but rather a potential consequence of the misuse or abuse of that gift in contradiction to God’s will.

Cain and Abel: A Biblical Illustration

This understanding directs us towards the narrative of Cain and Abel, the sons of Adam and Eve.

Despite being born into the era of sin’s dawn, they each held sole power over their actions.

Abel chose to honor God with his offerings while Cain allowed jealousy and wrath to navigate his path to fratricide.

Notably, God warned Cain of the lurking sin but emphasized that he had the ability to master it.

This underlines the robust intersectionality between free will and the potential for evil and grace.

The New Testament Perspective

Unveiling the Truth with the open pages of the New Testament
Unveiling the Truth with the open pages of the New Testament / jaflippo via iStock

Moreover, the New Testament reiterates these concepts, particularly in Paul’s letters, emphasizing the war waged within us between the spirit and the flesh.

Roman 7:15-20 lucidly outlines this struggle, highlighting how our free will can sometimes lead us into actions not according with our faith.

God’s Love and the Gift of Free Will

God’s profound love for humanity shines through the gift of free will, allowing us the freedom to choose our path, yet with it comes the responsibility to strive for choices pleasing to Him.

The capacity to choose good over evil is a testament to His trust and faith in us.

Our free will, therefore, is a tool for glorifying God, not an avenue for proliferating evil.

The Christian Call to Resist Evil

A man holding a Bible
A man holding a Bible / WANAN YOSSINGKUM via iStock

It is crucial, then, to underscore believers’ roles in persisting against sin.

Just as Christ was tempted yet remained sinless, Christians are emboldened to reflect the divine love by resisting evil persuasions.

Efforts are needed to consistently choose righteousness and honor God with our deeds, exemplifying the spirit of God’s love rising above the allure of the world.

The Root of Evil: Untethered Free Will

Artistic illustration of an evil
Artistic illustration of an evil / alessiozaccaria via Unsplash

Hence, the existence of evil cannot be considered as exclusively a result of human free will, but rather as a potential outcome when our free will becomes untethered from God’s divine ordinances.

Our journey as believers requires us to increasingly align our will to God’s will, choosing righteousness over sin, love over selfishness, and expressing a pervasive commitment to glorifying God with our gifted free will.

The final victory of God’s righteousness stands unshaken, serving as a beacon guiding us through our sojourn in this world.

Suffering and God’s Purpose

Constantly throughout scripture, there is a clear distinction drawn between the nature of humanity and the nature of God.

Psalms 18:30 reminds us that God’s way is perfect and his word tried and true.

In contrast, the human heart is described in Jeremiah 17:9 as deceitful above all things and desperately wicked.

The presence of suffering and evil therefore is not a contradiction of the Christian understanding of God as benevolent but is instead an accurate reflection of the propensity of humanity to abuse gifted free will.

Cain and Abel: Choices and Consequences

Worried man contemplates consequences of his choices
Worried man contemplates consequences of his choices / urbazon via iStock

To explore this further, the narrative of Cain and Abel intricately captures this reality.

Cain, born into a world already tainted by the sin of his parents, was not predetermined to be a murderer.

Yet, he allowed his anger, jealousy, and pride to lead him down a path of destruction.

His actions were a consequence of his choices, not a direct product of God’s plans.

It is not God who does evil, but humanity who often fall prey to it due to the misuse of free will.

The Spiritual Battle Within

Drawing from the teachings of Apostle Paul, it is clear that believers continually face a battle between spirit and flesh.

As written in Galatians 5:17, the flesh desires what is contrary to the Spirit, and vice versa.

This ongoing tussle between the call of our spiritual destiny and the gravitation of our human nature towards sin manifests in our daily living.

Therefore, the presence of evil and suffering can be perceived as a reflection of this struggle within us all, purposed to steer our alignment towards God’s will.

The Call to Spiritual Transformation

A man seeks solace, immersed in Bible reading and worship
A man seeks solace, immersed in Bible reading and worship / doidam10 via iStock

Similarly, the continuous call in the epistles of Paul for believers to present their bodies as a living sacrifice is a reminder of our role in transforming this narrative, as highlighted in Romans 12:1.

The emphasis is laid on reconnecting with the divine nature by regularly choosing righteousness over the temptation of the flesh.

This should center on honoring God with our deeds and reflecting Christ’s love, even when the allure of sin is daunting.

Suffering as an Opportunity for Growth

However, it is imperative to note that God does not abandon humanity to the throes of evil – rather he uses the presence of suffering as an opportunity for growth and perseverance.

As depicted in James 1:2-4, trials and temptations are instrumental in developing perseverance and maturity in the faith.

The Assurance of Eternal Hope

Jesus Christ with open arms
Jesus Christ with open arms / artplus via iStock

The presence of evil and suffering in our world is an unfortunate echo of the reality of human nature’s depraved propensity to freely choose sin.

However, in the entirety of its manifestations, it serves as a poignant reminder for believers to consistently strive towards aligning their will to God’s.

Our battles against the pull towards evil are not fought alone or in vain.

The victory of God’s righteousness over sin and evil, as foretold in Revelations 21:4, assures that there is indeed an eternal hope.

Unraveling the Mystery of Evil and Suffering

Although the presence of evil and suffering can be perplexing, understanding it comes down to recognizing the intrinsic relationship between free will, human nature, and God’s plan.

It provides an opportunity to not only appreciate the depth of God’s love but to revere his unchanging nature – pure, faithful and victorious against evil.

Our role as believers is to anchor on this truth, reflect his love and strive towards a life mirroring Christ’s example.

Two women comforting each other, showing Christ's love in action
Two women comforting each other, showing Christ’s love in action / FatCamera via iStock

At the heart of Christian theology lies the belief that God is loving, all-knowing and all-powerful.

Unpacking these characteristics in the context of suffering and evil raises challenging questions and unearths profound insights.

We’ve examined how God, in His love, gifted humanity with free will – a gift that, though fraught with the potential for evil, unequivocally underscores the value He places on freedom of choice.

We’ve also grappled with the theory of purposeful suffering, acknowledging the possibility that God allows pain to foster spiritual growth and resilience.

Ultimately, we are left with a nuanced understanding of evil’s origins, the role of free will, and the purpose of suffering.

It’s a compelling tapestry of divine mystery, human responsibility and transformative pain that gives rise to a theology as comforting as it is challenging.

Within this complex frame, we see a God who loves profoundly, a humanity endowed with consequential freedom, and a world where suffering can indeed serve a purpose.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Pure Presence Prayers | Connecting Through Faith

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Scroll to Top